Crucified freedom-in memoriam Mashal Khan and many other unknown victims of bigotry

A painfully lucid analysis of brutal chain of events in Pakistan and India. But how far are we from this? How did we end up with a Europe that is ruled by mediocrity and where the ugly face of fascism is rising again, winning places in national parliaments, generating “exits” from a the union of nations?
If there is something to mourn these days of holy days, then I feel that this time its Humanity that we should mourn. We silently crucify our valuable ideals, we hammer the nails of fear, prejudice, bigotry into the hands of our hopeful Future. We build walls instead of bridges and we hide in mindless fear and hate behind them. Where are our dreams and love of freedom, when we build prisons for ourselves inside those walls?
As this brave and wonderful young man writes in his piece of thought below, silence is not an answer.Silence is acceptance. Here you can read his point of view:

“Recently, Cow Vigilantes murdered Pehlu Khan, a dairy farmer over suspicion of cow slaughter. Now, over allegations of blasphemy, students murdered Mashal Khan in his own university. The first incident occurred in Alwar, India and the other one happened at Khyber-Phakhtunwala, Pakistan. Both incidents occurred in broad daylight.
Most people only speak when it hurts their community and remain silent when their own community is the perpetrator. This is hypocrisy at its worst.
Lynch Apologists say- “Killing is wrong, but one should not hurt the sentiments of the people”
By saying that they indirectly hold the victim responsible for his own murder. People should learn to take offense and still keep violence out of their response. Killing is wrong there is no ‘but’ to it.
Moreover, If your religion does not allow you to eat something, draw something or say something, don’t do it nobody is forcing you to, but don’t impose your own views upon others.
Some add, “These are the extremists, most people of this community are peaceful”
Killers of Pehlu Khan include an accounts’ teacher, a school physical trainer, three students, and one nurse. Killers of Mashal Khan were his own colleagues from his own university. In both incidents, perpetrators were not poor, uneducated or connected to any terrorist organization.
Which is responsible for it now? Lack of Education? Poverty? Radicalization? Or blind adherence to faith?! Or incredible zest to impose tenets of one’s own faith on others?!
One cannot rationalize one of these incidents without legitimizing the other. Those who ask for Sharia Law should not cry foul when Manuvadi Ram-Rajya befalls them. Both of these incidents are mirror images of each other. India is quite behind Pakistan in intolerance, but we are catching up fast. We should be wary of it.
Muslims should condemn Mashal Khan incident in the same vein as Alwar Lynching. Silence is not an answer. Silence is acceptance.” ( Azhar Khan)


Those of you who have not heard of Mashal Khan, here’s his last poem written shortly before his brutal death:

“”I am lost
It has been several weeks
that I filed a complaint before police
I go to police station daily ever since
and ask the station officer
Any clue about me?
The sympathetic police officer shakes his head in disappointment
He says in his shaking voice
That I found no clue about you
Then he consoles me
One day
you will be found
on a roadside
or critically injured
in a hospital
or dead
in some river
I get tears in my eyes
I leave for the market
to welcome me
buy some flowers from a flower shop
for my wounds
from the chemist
some bandage
some cotton
and pain-killers
for my funeral
a shroud from the shop near the mosque
and for remembering me
some candles
Some people say
when someone dies
candles should be not lit for them
but they don’t tell
that when the apple of some eye goes missing
where do you get the light from?
If the lamp of a house goes missing
what should they burn?”

No one should end up lynched. No one should be lynched for his ideas and ideals. No one should remain silent when such horrors occur. Because the moment we turn our heads and look aside, we open the door to murderous madness…. the one that sooner or later will set the whole world in fire the way it did too many times.

We owe to the memory of this young man, Mashal Khan to not let it fade away. We owe this to us and to the next generations. The time to speak up is now. The time to act is now.



A letter to India

The 9th  January 2014




Dear Sir,



My name is Mrs. Brindusa Poenaru and I am addressing You this letter from a far country, Romania/Europe.

I have great respect and admiration towards your country, your nation and your rich and diverse culture. I come from a very different one but we share one basic trait that unites us throughout the world. We are all humans.

We came from many different directions, we walked very different paths, we saw and experienced so many different things in our journey. Yet just as the colors of the rainbow, we ALL have to unite to create the purest light. Nobody can be left out from this unique combination or we’ll be forever left in the dark.

Just like a wise philosopher once said: “The goal of every intelligent being is to reach happiness”. And I’m sure that you know that the best way leading to happiness is LOVE. This is the one and only dream that lies in every human heart. This is the most beautiful connection between all of us, wherever we are.

I have written this letter to express my hope that my words would reach You and that you would reconsider the Supreme Court’s decision about Section 377. My deepest wish is that you get down this Section and stop criminalizing love.

As I wrote a few sentences before, we had come a long way in our common Human History. We live in a century that finally values human life and  individual rights. India has known a huge development and it’s a great country among the others. It was about time to take another step and make justice to some of her citizens that were grossly mistreated during history. In my opinion, the fact that section 377 had been turned down, and then reenacted it is an act of cruelty and disrespect towards those citizens of India who were directly affected.  I am fully aware that there is a lot of misunderstanding about the LGBTQ community but we will never be able to reconcile and surpass misrepresentation if we build walls between us and them.

Despite all reluctance and religious motivations, you have to keep in mind that these people are OUR children, our brothers and sisters, lawful citizens contributing with all their might and talent to the building of the country. They deserve to be treated equally and respectfully simply because they are CITIZENS. If you have concerns about morality, you can support the education and with learned and well informed citizens you won’t need laws to enforce morality. In my opinion, a healthy society is built upon the trust and respect and the free will of its citizens, not on spying on each other. Privacy is an important element of self-respect; please, don’t make “bedroom-laws”. They are meant only to trample on human dignity and I’m sure this is not your goal as an important and respected member of society.

Thank you for your undivided attention.

Sincerely yours

Brindusa Poenaru

Enhanced by Zemanta